Shifting our approach
by KEN ALMANZA
____________________________________________________________________________________
During a holiday break
in 2013, I told my mother about my decision to start taking Truvada as
PrEP (pre-exposure prophylaxis). I sat on her couch and also explained
that I was going to share my PrEP-taking journey on Facebook to educate
more people like myself. I waited for an argument to erupt. Discussion
about sexual health and freedom were usually met with negative feelings
in our household.
“¿Proph-a-que?” she shouted across the room.
I replied back with equal intensity: “It’s medication to prevent HIV
infection, mom!” Without missing a beat, she fired back with an arsenal
of questions: Isn’t HIV medication toxic? Why would you take a pill if
you are not sick? How are you going to pay for it? What will people
think of you? Do you already have HIV? Each question became more and
more saturated with uncertainty, fear, and misinformation. It almost
seemed as if I were “coming out” as gay all over again. But why was I
having this conversation with my mother in the first place? Let me
explain.
I come from a poor Mexican background and rarely
talked about sexuality, health care, or preventative medicine. In our
household, you would only go to the doctor if you were sick. Going to
the doctor also involved spending money and taking time off from work,
which potentially meant losing money. We were always trying to make ends
meet, so unless your arm was falling off, seeking medical care wasn’t a
top priority. Sex was something you learned about on your own, and the
gay thing? That was just something the family knew about but didn’t talk
about openly.
Growing up under those conditions amid a
high-context Mexican culture still influences my adult life today. In
the theory of high-context culture, relationships are emphasized, with
such matters as tone of voice and facial expressions more important than
mere words, giving way to respect—and trust. These cultural differences
can influence access to health care.
No matter my age, education, or how progressive I
think I am, maintaining a positive open relationship with my family
supersedes everything. Even at 28 years old, I was still seeking
acceptance. I am just one of many Latinx people who are bound by unique
cultural and socioeconomic drivers. These drivers can positively or
negatively affect our health outcomes. PrEP access for the Latinx
community means attachment to cultural constructs that community
educators, health centers, and medical providers are not always familiar
with.
For PrEP to be fully realized in the Latinx
community we can’t just translate English language resources into
Spanish and call it a day. We must reframe the entire conversation to
address real barriers many Latinx people face.
At the same time, we must propose realistic
solutions starting at the local level involving those who already serve
this population. We have the resources to implement PrEP on a larger
scale, but we must tailor our efforts to reflect the current needs of
Latinx people.
Recent data from Gilead Sciences noted that from
2012 to 2015 over 49,000 PrEP prescriptions were filled at pharmacies
across the nation. However, only 12% of those PrEP users were Hispanic.
This number did not surprise me. I know firsthand how immigration
status, stigma, culture, language, and gender identity can directly
affect PrEP uptake in the Latinx community.
Let’s look at one of the largest and most
vulnerable groups: The uninsurable undocumented population. Millions of
Latinx people are completely shut out of health insurance programs such
as Medicaid and the Affordable Care Act (ACA). This group stays largely
dependent on community clinics to address their health care needs.
However, unless a patient is located in a large urban city, there are
very few health centers actually dispensing PrEP in a community clinic
setting. To compound the problem, many clinics do not openly advertise
to undocumented populations, let alone understand how to implement
culturally competent services.
According to the CDC, Hispanics accounted for almost one quarter of all estimated new HIV diagnoses in 2013 (go to cdc.gov/hiv/group/racialethnic/hispaniclatinos).
A large portion of that Hispanic population is also undocumented, yet
we have no comprehensive health care or sustainable access points for
this group, meaning that funds run out and care is discontinued. Basic
costs for PrEP include co-pays for doctor visits, routine lab work, and
medication. Finding a sustainable payer source to cover these costs is
just one part of the equation. Most U.S.-born Latinx people have the
ability and luxury to sign up for insurance programs such as Medicaid,
ACA, or employer sponsored insurance plans.
However, even if successfully linked to an insurance plan, cultural barriers can still slow PrEP uptake.
For many Latinx people, medical providers are often
seen as authority figures and adhering to authority and power is a
cultural imperative. Because of this, medical providers will often need
to take the lead and initiate conversations about PrEP and HIV
prevention.
Activities and decisions among many Latinx cultures
are also based on interpersonal, face-to-face relationships. If a bond
is not developed from the beginning, a patient may not return for
subsequent visits.
A high level of self-efficacy is usually required
when requesting PrEP from a medical provider. Yet, many Latinx people
come from highly stigmatizing backgrounds where their own sexuality or
gender identity may have been scrutinized. For those with a strong
attachment to traditional gender roles and expectations comes another
set of barriers.
As a result, a Latinx patient may not always
possess the confidence or feel the need to advocate for their own sexual
health behind closed doors. A deep-rooted fear of judgment or
retaliation can sometimes block a Latinx patient from engaging in these
types of conversations, if at all. The situation can become a missed
opportunity if the medical provider does not fully understand the
patient’s sexual risk.
Health literacy and language also serve as a
substantial barrier. If a Latinx patient is not able to understand
health care systems or communicate ideas using English, PrEP will not
appear as a viable option. We must continually explore all of these
indicators in great detail, for they become the determining factor on
whether the Latinx community will choose to take PrEP and also whether
they will properly adhere to it.
HIV care providers have tirelessly worked through
the years to ensure that HIV-positive patients stay engaged in care. A
similar amount of work will be required to link and maintain
HIV-negative patients in care as well. We don’t necessarily need to
reinvent the wheel; we just need to tailor our approach to make PrEP
relevant to the communities we wish to serve.
It’s also highly important to note that PrEP is not
always the best HIV prevention option for every person. By no means
should we have an entire Latinx population dependent on biomedical
prevention for life. We don’t need to put it in the water.
We do, however, stand to benefit from having an
entire population successfully linked to comprehensive health care. The
common denominator is ensuring healthier, stronger communities. Even if a
patient chooses to come off of PrEP, they leave much more informed and
engaged with their health care than ever before.
Now is the time for community educators, health
centers, and medical providers to step up to the plate and deliver
culturally competent PrEP services. Local leaders can also push local
health officials into crafting better policies around PrEP access and
engagement. Latinx-based CBO s (community- based organizations) outside
of HIV prevention also play a role in PrEP uptake and awareness. In
order to make waves, we must change the narrative and develop a new
approach. We must bridge alliances, coordinate our efforts, and
contribute to a common goal.
The National HIV PrEP Summit (NHPS) is a new NMAC
conference that promises to contribute to that goal. Slated for December
3–4, 2016 in San Francisco, the meeting will be a partnership between
national and community-based organizations along with health departments
to focus on the implementation and infrastructure needed to turn the
promise of the science into an effective community HIV prevention
option.
Workshop sessions will focus on PrEP access and
engagement for various communities of color. Sessions will also cover
research, educational campaigns, program implementation, training
programs, health care providers, and policy. (To register and learn more
go to hivprepsummit.org.)
It’s 2016 and I have gone from educating my mother
in her living room, to educating constituents on a national level on how
to implement PrEP for people like me. After almost three years, I am
still adhering to my own PrEP regimen and believe it or not, my mother
has become an active PrEP supporter as well. It took time and education,
but she now advocates for health care access and PrEP use within her
own social networks.
If my own mom is doing outreach, there is no reason
you can’t as well. Let’s get to work and change our approach. We have a
community to protect.
KEN ALMANZA
is an HIV prevention and health advocate and currently serves as
Program Associate for NMAC. Originally from Los Angeles, Ken has worked
extensively in communities of color as an HIV/STD test counselor,
behavioral intervention specialist, and PrEP navigator. His ultimate
goal is to help create safe, healthy environments through open, honest
discussion and effective community collaborations.
Read more articles from Positively Aware, here.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.